The German Cross of Honour for the German Mother award, 1938 – 1944

BY RICHARD MADDOX

BEING A MUSEUM OF SOCIAL HISTORY looking at the experience of British and Commonwealth nations in times of conflict from World War One onwards, IWM’s collection is vast and diverse.

And of course there are always some surprises.

Take for instance the enamelled award below, part of the IWM’s collection.

Ehrenkreuz der Deutschen Mutter (First Class) Image © R Maddox 2017.

Officially named the Ehrenkreuz der Deutschen Mutter (the Cross of Honour for the German Mother) or more simply the Mutterkreuz or Mother’s Cross, it was instituted by Adolf Hitler on 16 December 1938 (the rear of the award shows this date and a facsimile of the Fuhrer’s signature) (1) as part of a campaign to increase the birth rate following the deaths in the First World War and the Influenza pandemic at the end of the conflict.

The rear of the same award. Image © R Maddox 2017.

The medal was conferred in three separate classes or grades and awarded on the basis of how many children a woman had given raised.

  • Gold Cross: First Class Award, bestowed on eligible mothers with eight or more children
  • Silver Cross: Second Class Award, awarded to eligible mothers with six or seven children
  • Bronze Cross: Third Class Award, for eligible mothers with four to five children

But the medal wasn’t just for becoming pregnant and successfully giving birth.

It directly supported the three ‘Ks’ of German society in the 1930s; Kinder (children), Kirche (church) and Küche (kitchen) (2) – all of which were considered important and had a great impact on the lives of women at the time.

There were strict conditions that were attached to the award that had to be satisfied by lengthy and through bureaucratic investigation by local government agencies and the police.

For example, the mother and her husband had to be ‘deutschblütig’; that is of ‘pure’ German bloodline or ancestry (under German law at the time this phrase also included both sets of grandparents of the new baby) and a signed affidavit had to be produced to this effect.

The parents also had to be physically and mentally fit and not alcohol or drug dependent.

The mother had to be ‘honourable’ and ‘worthy’ of the decoration. She had to be able to prove no evidence of prostitution, marital infidelity, having intimate relationships that were contrary to the race laws at the time or unlawful abortion.

She (and her husband) had not to have been in prison and be able to prove that they were not having children to avoid work or attempting to live solely on state child benefit or have behaved in any way that could question their moral standing and reputation.

If she or her family failed to meet the criteria they risked being seen as dysfunctional and ultimately a risk to and burden on the state.

Having the award granted privileges.

A German national newspaper stated in 1938 that ‘…the holder of the Mother’s Cross of Honour will in future enjoy all types of privileges that we by nature have accustomed to our nation’s honoured comrades and our injured war veterans.’ (3)

In practice this meant that award holders could get better rations, have priority for seats on public transport and practical local help to assist with the care of the children. Members of German youth groups were required to salute the wearer of the award and greet her in a respectful manner.

Once awarded, the mother still had to behave appropriately. If she neglected her children or behaved in a way that was contrary to the criteria of the award it could be revoked.

There was also provision that Adolf Hitler would become a godfather to the tenth child in any eligible family (4).

Interestingly given the at times quasi-religious ceremonies of German National Socialist and Workers Party the colours of the medal and ribbon are seen in some quarters as a nod to the traditional colours that the Mary, the Mother of Christ is often depicted wearing (5).

It is estimated that some 4.7 million awards were issued between its inception in 1938 and 1944 when the awards ceased (6).  The first award ceremony was held on 12 August 1938 as Hitler’s mother (Klara) mother was born on that day in 1860 (7).

 

More information and sources:

(1) http://www.germanmilitaria.com/Political/photos/N013978.html

(2) http://www.bbc.co.uk/schools/gcsebitesize/history/tch_wjec/germany19291947/2economicsocialpolicy3.shtml

(3) The Völkischer Beobachter (People’s Observer) national newspaper (1938 Issue No. 25) stated (English translation of the original German text) : “…the holder of the Mother’s Cross of Honour will in future enjoy all types of privileges that we by nature have accustomed to our nation’s honoured comrades and our injured war veterans.”

(4) http://germanhistorydocs.ghi-dc.org/sub_image.cfm?image_id=2044 (5) http://www.catholic-saints.info/catholic-symbols/symbolism-of-colors.htm

(6) https://www.nationalholocaustcentre.net/gold-mothers-cross

(7) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Klara_Hitler

Advertisements

A Stirling effort: a crew from No. 622 Squadron, RAF debrief following a raid to Berlin, 22-23 November 1943. But why is the female RAF Intelligence officer out of the picture?

BY RICHARD MADDOX

ROYAL AIR FORCE BOMBER COMMAND, 1941-1945. (CH 11640). Copyright: © IWM. Original Source: http://www.iwm.org.uk/collections/item/object/205213014

THE TWO IMAGES shown here are from the online IWM Collection and were taken by Pilot Officer A Goodchild (an official RAF photographer) on the same night and at the same place.

They show two Short Stirling bomber crews being debriefed by two Intelligence Officers, one male and one female on the results of their mission.

Except that in the published image you would not have seen the female officer.

So why  has the official censor (or the picture editor of the publication the image was to be used in) decided to crop out the WRAF Intelligence Officer conducting the debrief as well as the two other airmen (one hidden behind her)?

Given that the Stirling was manned by a crew of seven, there are two men missing from the suggested cropped image, one to the left of the WRAF and another (difficult to see) behind her head and all those seated could conceivably be from the same crew with the airman leaning in being from another.

The caption which accompanies this image is long and detailed with the Squadron number, the date of the raid to Berlin, the RAF Station the crew have returned to (Mildenhall), the number of aircraft  that took off (764) and names of just the five airman to the right of the vertical line as well as some information about their ultimate fate.

As the material is available from the IWM Collections website I have focused on just the names of those depicted in the main part of the photograph. The man leaning in and three others in the background are not named on the caption.

… Seated left to right are: Pilot Office R J Brown (captain), Sergeant W Brodie (flight engineer), Sergeant F Forde (wireless operator/air gunner), Flight Sergeant P Harwood (bomb aimer) and Sergeant F E Tidmas (navigator). With the exception of Harwood, all were to perish over Berlin on the night of 30/31 January 1944 in an Avro Lancaster of the Squadron.

The caption for the second image (also taken by Goodchild on the same night at the same debrief) shows and names all the seven crew as well as the (male) Intelligence Officer ,

This too is part of the online IWM Collection. It has the same introductory information in its caption as the previous image and again I have focused on the names of those central to the image. What happened to the crew is not specified,

THE STRATEGIC BOMBING OF GERMANY, 1942-1945 (CH 11641).  Copyright: © IWM. Original Source: http://www.iwm.org.uk/collections/item/object/205210950

The relevant part of the caption reads:

Those shown are (left to right): Flight Lieutenant R D Mackay (navigator), Flying Officer G Dunbar (interrogating officer), Sergeant J Towns (rear gunner, partly hidden by Dunbar), Pilot Officer K Pollard (wireless operator), Flight Sergeant C Stevenson (second pilot, standing), Squadron Leader J Martin (captain and flight commander), Sergeant W Rigby (mid-upper gunner), Flying Officer Grainger (bomb aimer) and Sergeant H Fletching (flight engineer).

According to historian Martin Middlebrook (1), Air Chief Marshal Arthur Harris, having been briefed on ‘near perfect’ conditions for the attackers ordered a ‘maximum effort’ raid on Berlin.

Seven hundred and sixty four aircraft took off for the raid, the greatest number sent to Berlin at this point in the war.

Only No. 617 Squadron (by now recognised as a specialist bomber squadron and two De Havilland Mosquito squadron equipped with OBOE, (specialist bombing guidance equipment) were exempt from the order to fly that night.

The raid would be led by Pathfinder aircraft equipped with an air-to-ground radar to enable them to ‘see’ through smoke and cloud to the target below and mark it with flares for the main bomber force.

Of the aircraft taking part fifty would be Short Stirlings, the first of the four-engined bombers to enter RAF service but now out performed by newer designs.

Twelve of these returned early to base with mechanical problems without bombing, meaning that although the overall loss rate of 3.4% of the total number of aircraft despatched, the loss rate for the slower and lower – flying aircraft was appreciably higher.

This was the last time Stirlings were sent to bomb Germany.

Very heavy cloud on the way to and over Berlin grounded the Luftwaffe night fighters and stopped searchlight illuminating the bombers for the German guns.

Despite the weather, the raid was seen as perhaps the most effective of all those on the German capital .

During the 22 minutes scheduled for the attack, aircraft were to bomb the target at a rate of 34 a minute, starting at 19:58.

Around 2000 people were killed on the ground that night, including 500 when a public air raid shelter at Wilmersdorf was destroyed.(2)

So to return to the original question, why was the female officer removed?

I  have no definite answer.

By this time the general public in the warring countries knew that women were serving in the armed forces in a variety of roles.

Although away from the front line, these roles – particularly in a naval dockyard, air force station or headquarters building –  all carried the threat of death or injury to some extent.

If it was to protect her identity for some reason the film negative could have been destroyed with nobody any wiser or the photographer (a servicing RAF officer presumably used to giving and receiving orders) simply told not to take it.

And there we have it – another unanswered mystery…

AS USUAL WITH ALL OUR POSTS IF YOU HAVE FURTHER INORMATION WE WOULD LIKE TO HEAR FROM YOU!

SOURCES:

(1) The Berlin Raids R.A.F Bomber Command Winter 1943 – 44 Martin Middlebrook (1990)

(2) The RAF Pathfinders Martyn Chorlton (2012)

The Unassuming Accountant – Flying Officer John Gillies, RAF

BY RICHARD MADDOX

This is the final of a three-part post about Sir Harold Gillies and written by IWM London volunteers Dr. Jess Pocock and myself, with Jess writing the first in the series.

The companion pieces are ‘The Surgeon’ and ‘The Patient’.

ON 23 MAY 1940 FATE DEALT A CRUEL BLOW as it had done so often before and would continue to do so.

Pilot Officer John Arthur Gillies of No. 92 Squadron RAF failed to return from a patrol over the French coast at 17:00. The initial cryptic signal received by the RAF’s Casualty Section just before midnight on 24 May attributed the loss to enemy action. He was the eldest son of the eminent plastic surgeon Sir Harold Delf Gilles.

It also stated that ‘Gillies was missing (believed killed)’ (1). Telegrams were then sent to his wife Ellen in Liverpool (they had married in February 1940) and his father in Hampstead.

In view of the importance of Sir Harold’s work with the RAF a Group Captain Powers had asked to be informed of any developments in John’s case – presumably to act as a support for the family.

By June 14 it was clear that John was a Prisoner of War.

An international Red Cross telegram had been received listing him and nine other airmen as being at Dulag Luft, (Durschgangslager der Luftwaffe – Luftwaffe Transit Camp)  – the Luftwaffe’s aircrew reception and interrogation centre to which all captured airmen were sent before continuing on to a prisoner of war camp (2).

The telegram ends with the words ‘Tous Bien’ – all is well.

While he was at Dulag Luft he became a member of the camp’s Permanent British Staff and became was Cookhouse Officer (3).

John, a chartered accountant by profession who had served with No. 604 (County of Middlesex) Squadron, Royal Auxiliary Air Force before the war, would be imprisoned until its end, returning home after his prison camp was liberated.

On 17 May 1945, with the Victory in Europe celebrations more than a week old and the imminent end to the war in Europe in sight, his father made enquiries as to when his son would arrive home.

He left a message that a Squadron Leader Byrne (4) at No. 106 Personnel Resettlement Centre (one of three centres set up for returning liberated prisoners of war at this time) could contact him with details of his son’s arrival. Byrne had also been imprisoned in Stalag Luft III before being repatriated in 1944 (5).

But of course there were many things to be done before John was truly home. Like all former prisoners of war he had to provide the authorities with details of his experiences as a captive.

He was asked to complete at least two questionnaires – one from P4 Casualty Branch who were attempting to find and identify missing airmen and another from MI 9 a department of Military Intelligence established to help evading airmen return to the UK by supporting resistance networks in Occupied Europe.

His P4 Casualty questionnaire is attached to his casualty file (6).

Completed around 21 June 1945 it bears only his neatly written name, rank and serial number, together with the number of his squadron and the date of his capture. Details of his aircraft, where he was captured and other information are left blank.

With the war in Europe over, MI9 (and its sub-division Intelligence School 9 – IS 9 (7)) were interested in the former prisoner’s experience of capture and subsequent imprisonment. They were concerned with securing the prosecution of enemy personnel who had maltreatment prisoners or indeed allied prisoners who may have collaborated as well as recognising those individuals who had helped aided Allied airmen.

On 23 May 1945 he completed his Liberated POW Questionnaire. Here too he wrote little – but showed an accountant’s mind for detail and exactitude.

Although not specifically asked to do so, he gave his prisoner of war number (626), disclosed that he had been with No. 604 Squadron, was uncertain of his date of enlistment (‘approx. April 1932 in R.A.F.O. class A.A. (ii)’) and that he was interrogated at Dulag Luft in June 1940.

All other questions about his experience as a prisoner of war are crossed through, answered with ‘NO’ or both.

And at the end he signed a neat signature and the date (8).

AT THIS POINT I MUST ADMIT TO BE A LITTLE DISAPPOINTED with my research. Having made up my mind that there was nothing more to be found, for some strange reason I turned the page over.

Why I don’t know. But I did. And what I did made interesting reading.

I turned the page to find another with two testimonials, one from Group Captain Richard Kellett, RAF, the Senior British Officer at Stalag Luft III and the second from Wing Commander Harry Day.

large_R_Kelletpixl

The then Wing Commander Richard Kellett RAF Commanding Officer of No. 149 Squadron RAF at RAF Mildenhall, Cambridgeshire. Image © IWM C439.

Kellett was flying as a second pilot on Vickers Wellington bomber on 18 December 1939 when the aircraft was shot down. His was one of nine aircraft lost from the force of twenty four. A further six ditched in the sea or make emergency landings at other airfields. He managed to evade capture for a week in September 1942 before he was caught (9).

The Citation for the award of his Distinguished Flying Cross in January 1940 (awarded for leading the attack in December 1939) notes that “… by his personal example and cool leadership he won the confidence of all pilots under him (10).

His testimonial to Gillies’ work reads:

‘… From its inception he was responsible for the coding and decoding of messages to and from home. For the last 3 years he was in sole charge in East Camp Luft III for this particular work, Involving all special letter writing and wireless messages, training and supervision of operators and the security of the whole system.

He notes that because of his immense work load Gillies was ‘practically precluded from indulging in any personal interests and that over this period he wrote nearly 200 letters introducing and modifying codes as necessary. He did all this without a break from his duties and without the Germans discovering his activities.

Gillies_POW_Questionnaire_4AZred

The testimonials of Group Captain Kellet and Wing Commander Day on the back of John Gillies’ POW Questionnaire contained in file WO 399/114/1. Image © R Maddox 2017.

Originally a Royal Marines officer Harry Arbuthnot Melville Day transferred to the Fleet Air Arm in 1924. During the First World War he won an Albert Medal (the equivalent of the George Cross) for saving two trapped men on HMS Britannia when the ship was torpedoed off Cape Trafalgar in November 1918 – just two days before the Armistice. He then joined the RAF in 1930 (11) (12).

Known as ‘Wings’ Day he was the first British officer imprisoned at Dulag Luft, having been shot down when his Bristol Blenheim reconnaissance aircraft (was attacked by Luftwaffe fighter aircraft on Friday 13 October 1939.

Although he and his fellow crew members Sergeant Eric Hillier (the observer) and AC2 Frederick Moller (the wireless operator/air gunner) all managed to leave the stricken aircraft, Day – who was also the newly appointed Commanding Officer of No. 57 Squadron and was forty years old at the time – was the sole survivor, receiving burns to his hands and face (13).

Whilst in captivity he was made Senior British Officer at Dulag Luft. He used his position to build a relationship with senior German personnel to win them over and thus gain intelligence insights which he sent back to London. He would also debrief newly arrived prisoners on the interrogation methods they were subjected to and their general welfare. In addition he started writing coded letters after being shown by a fellow prisoner

So successful was he in building these relationships that other prisoners genuinely suspected him of collaborating and reported their suspicions after the war (14).

Day was awarded a DSO and an OBE in December 1945 (15).

His testimony reads: ‘His duties as camp Accountant Officer i/c Coding were most painstaking and arduous, and at no time was it necessary to even check over his work, and he carried  them [all his duties] out with good temper and great ability(16).

Further research informed me that a third of each officer’s pay was diverted to the Communal Fund used to pay for a variety of things from furniture to bills for damages, additional rations from the German canteen as well as items needed by the camp’s Escape Committee (17).

This fund was administered by Gillies after he took over the post from a Flight Lieutenant R G Stark RNZAF when Stark was transferred to another part of Stalag Luft III.

Account books with their strings of numbers and cryptic headings can be a natural place for codes.

Gillies as a member of the Coding Staff, would have been given intelligence material gleaned from overheard conversations, mission details from newly captured aircrew as well as any intelligence that was gained by trading food stuffs, personal items etc. with German personnel by the camp’s Code Intelligence Officer, and then approved by the Senior British Officer and his own Intelligence Officer. (18)

He then would turn this into a coded message that was sent back to England, sometimes by hidden radio (as in the post on this blog ‘Captain Shackleton’s gift to the Imperial War Museum’) or in a coded letter.

In order to keep messages secure, codes had to be updated or devised from scratch. Gillies and another RAF officer devised a new code during June and July 1943 and managed to have the information sent to London. (19)

There was a real skill in constructing these messages as not only had the message to be hidden in ‘normal’ English it also had to contain no word or phrase that would be deleted by the German censors.

In December 1945 John was awarded an MBE for his wartime services (20) and may have moved back to the land of his birth as there is an award to a John Arthur Gillies MBE of the New Zealand Queen’s Service Order for Community Service (21) in the 1986 New Year’s Honours List.

It is perhaps significant in the way that John lead his life that I could find only one picture of him (on a website describing his crash) and that I haven’t been able to establish definitely if he did returned to New Zealand or even what he did in his post-war life.

As usual if there is anything that can be added to this story please let us know.

SOURCES AND FOOTNOTES:

(1) Air 81/509 – enclosure 1A. UK National Archives, Kew, England.

(2) ibid – enclosure 5A. UK National Archives, Kew, England.

(3)Dulag Luft – The German Aircrew Interrogation Centre’. After the Battle magazine number 106, pages 14.

(4) This is probably Vincent “Paddy” Byrne, serving with No.74 Squadron RAF and captured when his Spitfire was shot down over France also on 23 May 1940.  See file Air 81/506 UK National Archives, Kew, England.

(5) http://wlajournal.com/webcontent/malingering/malingering.pdf – accessed 3 August 2017

(6) Air 81/509 – enclosure 13. UK National Archives, Kew, England.

(7) http://discovery.nationalarchives.gov.uk/details/r/C14414 – accessed 3 August 2017

(8) WO 399/114/1. UK National Archives, Kew, England.

(9) http://www.rafweb.org/Biographies/Kellett.htm – accessed 5 August 2017

(10) https://www.thegazette.co.uk/London/issue/34773/ page 301 – accessed 5 August 2017

(11) http://www.flyingmarines.com/Biographies/1921-1930/Day.htm – accessed 28 October 2017

(12) https://www.haileybury.com/medals/george_cross.htm – accessed 28 October 2017

(13) AIR 81/27 – UK National Archives, Kew England.

(14) Dulag Luft – The German Aircrew Interrogation Centre’After the Battle magazine number 106 – page 8.

(15) http://www.flyingmarines.com/Biographies/1921-1930/Day.htm – accessed 28 October 2017

(16) WO 399/114/1. UK National Archives, Kew, England.

(17) Stalag Luft III: An Official History of the POW Camp of the Great Escape. John Grehan, pubished by Frontline Books (2017) – page 12.

(18) ibid – page 65.

(19) ibid – page 70.

(21) https://www.thegazette.co.uk/London/issue/37405/supplement/6283/data.pdf

(21) https://www.thegazette.co.uk/London/issue/50362/supplement/30/data.pdf

Special thanks are due to Ernie Henty who kindly lent me his copy of ‘After the Battle’ Magazine when I had been unsuccessful in finding a copy. Not only that, but he then ordered me my own copy!

The Patient – Flying Officer Thomas Gilbert Pace, No. 85 Squadron RAF

BY RICHARD MADDOX

This is the second of a three-part post about the eminent surgeon Sir Harold Gillies written by Dr. Jess Pocock and Richard Maddox, IWM London Volunteers.

The others in the series are ‘The Surgeon’ and ‘The Unassuming Accountant’.

PILOT OFFICER THOMAS GILBERT PACE, RAF – nicknamed ‘Ace’ Pace – was shot down south of Ath in Belgium on 15May 1940.  He sustained severe burns to his hands and face and was placed on the ‘Dangerously Ill’ list on the following day (1).

In a letter dated 2 November 1940 to a Miss Peggy McFarlane of Montreal he describes his crash and his treatment as a patient of Harold Gillies (2). He starts at a point in late April when he and Peggy had gone shopping in Cambridge and then relates how a few days later on May 4 he arrived at his new squadron ‘in time for lunch’.

He was made to feel very welcome and met his former Flight Commander from his Flying Training School there. After general familiarisation and getting used to flying a Hawker Hurricane. He had previously flown Supermarine Spitfires with No. 19 Squadron RAF  – which he preferred – until he had been posted to No.85 Squadron ”somewhere in France’ on 26 April 1940 (3).

Based at RAF Duxford – now the site of IWM Duxford – No.19 Squadron  was the first squadron to be equipped with the type in August 1938.

May 10, 1940 – the first day of the ‘Blitzkreig’ German invasion of France and the Low Countries – was also Pace’s first day of action in France.

Although not mentioned in his letter – which of course had to be approved by wartime censors – his ‘new squadron was No. 85 Squadron, based at Lille-Seclin and part of the 60 Fighter Wing, Air Component, British Expeditionary Force  (4)(5). The Wing’s role was to support French and British ground operations. Offensive bombing was carried out by the other RAF organisation in France at the time, the Advanced Air Striking Force.(6)

Pace was a member of No. 85 Squadron’s ‘A’ Flight (7).

On 10 May 1940 the squadron was on alert from 03:40 with some aircraft flying at 04:00 (5) but he would not be airborne until 17:30 when he chased a damaged enemy aircraft but had to give up as his fuel reserves were low. Later that day he and two fellow pilots came across ‘35 Heinkels bombing a town’.

The three RAF aircraft were soon joined by others making the odds 12 against 35. He writes that 27 of the German bombers from that raid were destroyed.

He shot down one of the bombers and ‘believe me it was a satisfying sight when I think what they were doing lately. When his particular combat was over (as seemed to happen so often in these type of accounts) he found the sky empty of aircraft.

Landing back at his airfield he gave his ground crew a thumbs up sign and received an ecstatic response.

large_No85_Hurri

Their work done for the moment, groundcrew of No. 85 Squadron RAF take a few minutes to relax while a Hurricane fighter sits at readiness at Lille-Seclin, November 1939. Image by Mr H Hensser, official photoographer © IWM (C 460)

 

You should have seen them singing and dancing.  I felt glad I didn’t let them down.’

Later that same day he would account for another Heinkel.

That night there was a ‘terrific party in the Mess‘ as soon as they were stood down and he went to bed at 2am, having consumed nothing but orange juice and was awake an hour later. He flew again that day but did not encounter any enemy aircraft.

Wednesday 15 May 1940 and the Netherlands fell to the German advance. Pace and his colleagues were in action again – after another late night when they returned from ‘the town’ at 02:30 to be up an hour later.

The town in question may have been Lille, about 10 kilometres (six miles) from Fretin where the officers of No. 85 Squadron were billeted.

The squadron had moved from Lesquin – officers to a chateau, which had been owned by the Duke of Marlorough in 1708 with NCOs and men to billets in the village of Ennetierre – around 13 May when the squadron’s Officer Commanding, Squadron Leader J O W Oliver decided that Lesquin ‘was unhealthy due to the fact that there was a munitions factory in the village’ (8).

Airborne that morning at 11:00 with two of the squadron’s other pilots (Pilot Officers Allen and Ashton), together they attacked a group of 15 German bombers.

Pace set one on fire.

Then he was too was attacked, possibly by a Messerschmitt bf110 escort as he describes being hit by 20mm cannon shells.

His engine faltered.

Smoke came from under the dashboard. His aircraft had the oil pipe severed and cannon shells damaged the underwing radiator.

Then his radio was shot out.

Knowing how valuable his aircraft was – given the losses the squadron was experiencing – he decided to force-land in a field.

Unfortunately as he came in low, blinded by smoke he hit a tree with his right (starboard) wing.

As I hit the ground there was a terrific pop and the whole thing was a mass of flame.’

The force of the landing jammed the canopy (which he had previously opened in case he needed to parachute out) shut. The forward fuel tank behind the instrument panel exploded, showering his right thigh with burning fuel.

With the flames taking hold he heaved at the canopy and managed to open it. Then his parachute caught on his seat. Somehow he cleared it and threw himself out of the burning cockpit.

But his troubles were far from over.

He fell onto the port wing, landing on his shoulder in the burning port fuel tank .

He rolled on the ground to put out the fire on his clothing and body. Picking himself up he walked half a mile until he met an Army motorcyclist who summoned an ambulance.

‘I climbed into it myself and very nearly passed out but I managed it and climbed out the other end. Then they put me to sleep and I woke up a fortnight later in the hospital’.

He was eventually evacuated to England, arriving first at Exeter Hospital before coming to Prewett Hospital near Basingstoke in Hampshire. Gillies and his team established their reconstructive surgery unit away from the main hospital buildings at Rooksdown House, a former private wing when the hospital was an asylum.

Sir Harold Gillies the famous plastic surgeon is working on me. He has given me two new eyelids and put my nose straight, the broken cheek bone mended itself because they only found it out when I pointed out a little lump on my cheek that I could feel but couldn’t see’.

At the time of writing to Peggy (2 November 1940) he has already had four operations. In his letter he says that he wants to go back to flying with his squadron and having been seen by a medical board he was told he could do so after his final surgical operation, which he was hoping to be in three months hence.

large_T_G_PACE_Mousetrap

Flying Officer Pace, ‘The Mousetrap’ and an unnamed dog. Part of the private papers of T G Pace, held by Imperial War Museums, reference: Documents 11775

In his final paragraphs he writes that he hopes to get his sports car (named ‘The Mousetrap’) to the hospital as it will save him money on bus and taxi fares.

And although Gillies and his fellow doctors encourage their patients to drink beer ‘as soon as I’ve been discharged I am going back to orange juice’.

large_No85_PaceHDR

Pilots of No. 85 Squadron RAF pause for a photograph between sorties at Lille-Seclin, at 9am on May 10, 1940 first day of the German invasion of France. They had been intercepting German aircraft since 4.15am and were to continue to do so until 9pm that evening. They claimed seventeen enemy aircraft destroyed for the loss of four Hawker Hurricanes.
Back row, (left to right); Flight Lieutenant J R M Boothby, Flying Officer T G Pace, Squadron Leader J O W “Doggie” Oliver (Commanding Officer), Pilot Officer J H Ashton, Pilot Officer J W Lecky, Flying Officer S P Stephenson, Sergeant G ‘Sammy’ Allard, Sergeant L A Crozier and Warrant Officer Newton: Front, (left to right); Flying Officer K H Blair and Sergeant J McG Little.
Image © IWM (C 1514)

Eventually he recovered enought and returned to operational flying but on 3 December 1941 he and his aircraft were lost without trace.

He is commemorated on the Air Forces Memorial to the Missing at Runnymede in Surrey, England (9) as one of the 20,456 men and women who served in the British and Commonwealth air forces and have no known grave.

FOOTNOTES:

No 85 Squadron RAF was one of four regular RAF squadrons sent to France in September 1939.

It can be difficult to directly match the claims of the squadron to the official Operational Record Book as this was reconstructed later from a variety of sources after the RAF had withdrawn from France on 21 May 1940.

Between 10 and 21 May 1940 not only did the RAF launch attacks on enemy forces, RAF airfields were in turn bombed. Lille Seclin was attacked on at least four occasions but luckily casualties were few. However only four of No. 87 Squadron’s aircraft returned to England (10).

Some would be cannibalised, put back into service or stripped for parts by men like Pilot Officer Louis Strange DFC and Bar (see the post ‘Louis Arbon Strange – a man with a DFC in the First World War and another in the Second’).

Pilot Officer Patrick Philip Woods – Scawen (see ‘Brothers in Arms’ post) was a contemporary of Pace, serving with ‘B’ Flight, No. 85 Squadron RAF at the same time.

He would die on 1 September 1940 with his brother being killed the next day.

SOURCES:

The primary source for this post was the letter cited at (2) below.

(1) UK National Archives file reference AIR 81/403 Flying Officer T G Pace injured; Hurricane N2656 failed to return from an operational flight, 15 May 1940.

(2) Manuscript letter  written by Flight Lieutenant while recovering at Park Prewitt Hospital. IWM catalogue reference: Documents 11775. Selected images can be viewed at
http://www.iwm.org.uk/collections/item/object/1030011651 – consulted 3 July 2017

(3) No. 19 Squadron RAF Operations Record Book, Air 27/252. UK National Archives – consulted 30 May 2017

(4) http://www.niehorster.org/017_britain/40-05_bef/bef_air_ac.html – Retrieved 1 August 2017.

(5) http://www.niehorster.org/017_britain/009_symbols_raf.html – Retrieved 1 August 2017.

(6) https://www.rafmuseum.org.uk/research/online-exhibitions/history-of-the-battle-of-britain/phoney-air-war-in-france.aspx – Retrieved 1 August 2017.

(7) No. 85 Squadron RAF Operations Record Book, Air 27/703. – entry for 10 May 1940. UK National Archives – consulted 30 May 2017

(8) No. 85 Squadron RAF Operations Record Book, Air 27/703. – entry for 13 May 1940. UK National Archives – consulted 30 May 2017

(9) Commonwealth War Graves Commission – Thomas Gilbert Pace Casualty Result  https://www.cwgc.org/find-war-dead/casualty/1803727/pace,-thomas-gilbert/ – Retrieved 1 August 2017.

(10) http://www.epibreren.com/ww2/raf/87_squadron.html Roland Beaumont – Retrieved 1 August 2017.

 

 

The Surgeon – Sir Harold Gillies (1882-1960)

BY DR. JESSICA POCOCK B.Sc.,M.B.,Ch.B.,M.R.C.Ophth

This is the first of a three-part post about the work of eminent surgeon Sir Harold Gillies that IWM London volunteers Dr. Jess Pocock and Richard Maddox have written together.

The others (‘The Patient’ and ‘The Unassuming Accountant’) will follow.

IN 1930 TWO COUSINS MET FOR THE FIRST TIME.
Archibald MacIndoe, a young gastric surgeon, arrived in London from America and contacted his cousin in the hope of finding a post in a London hospital.

This meeting was to have enormous consequences in the Second World War because the older cousin was Harold Gillies, by then a celebrated plastic surgeon who had changed the future of reconstructive surgery through his pioneering work during the Great War. MacIndoe started work at St. Bartholomew’s hospital, and soon changed course to become a leading expert in plastic surgery.

Harold Delf Gillies was born in New Zealand in 1882 but came to England to study Medicine at Cambridge and St. Bartholomew’s hospital. He became a Fellow of the Royal College of Surgeons in 1910 and by 1914 was on course for a successful career in Ear, Nose and Throat (ENT) surgery.

However, the outbreak of war was soon followed by a huge demand for medical officers to cope with the alarming numbers of casualties and Gillies, along with many colleagues, volunteered in early 1915.

gillies 03A

Harold Gillies during his service with the Royal Army Medical Corps during the First World War. Image by kind permission of Dr Andrew Bamji FRCP

As a Captain in the Royal Army Medical Corps he was posted to a Base hospital at Wimereux, France, where he worked as a General surgeon. Here he met Charles Valadier, an experienced dental surgeon, who was campaigning for specialist reconstructive plastic and jaw surgical units. Both men were appalled by the number of facial wounds caused by shrapnel and soon Gillies was assisting Valadier in the first specialised plastic unit at Wimereux.

They, together with a slightly more experienced American surgeon, C.W. Roberts, were helped by a newly published book on surgery for “Mutilated Soldiers”, by Lindemann, a German surgeon.

The main aim of reconstructive surgery at that time was to return the soldiers to active service as soon as possible. However, Gillies realised that thousands of soldiers were left so disfigured that they would rather die. He was shocked that so little attention was given to the cosmetic outcome of surgery and he became convinced that specialist hospitals must be set up in England.

“War is the only proper school for surgeons”

Hippocrates c460-377 BC

By the end of 1915 he was recalled to England and, with Colonel Sir William Lane, planned an experimental specialist unit. Progress was rapid and this first unit opened in Aldershot in February 1916.

At this point Gillies may have lacked experience, most of which was in general and ENT surgery, but he more than compensated for this with tremendous drive, enthusiasm and tireless work.

He read all the books and the ancient texts – for plastic surgery is an ancient art. He tried every known technique and developed methods such as using living tissues from the same patient for reconstruction, instead of implanting foreign material which had previously been tried, but with relatively poor long-term success.

large_© IWM (Art.IWM ART 3659)

‘The Queen’s Hospital for Facial Injuries, Frognal, Sidcup: The Operating Theatre’, an oil painting by J Hodgson Lobley, 1918. © IWM (Catalogue reference: IWM ART 3659)

By 1916 the unit had outgrown its premises and moved to Frognal, near Sidcup in Kent. The staff now included nurses, radiologists, dental surgeons, photographers, plaster technicians and office personnel – often ex-patients. Professor Henry Tonks, from the Slade School of Art, created a permanent record of all the operations performed. His famous illustrations survive to this day (1).

The Battle of the Somme (July – November 1916) produced a dramatic rise in the number of casualties and at one stage some 2,000 patients were admitted over 10 days.

By now there was also a need for accommodation for patients between surgical procedures, as most needed several staged operations, and further facilities for convalescence and rehabilitation.

Another move was necessary, this time to Queen Mary’s Hospital, Sidcup and the team expanded and included surgeons from Canada, Australia, New Zealand and America.

This famous unit, set up in August 1917, was headed by Gillies.

He developed and adapted a Russian technique of “tube pedicle grafts” which preserved the original blood supply of a graft while it established itself on a new site, in another part of the body. This method minimised the risk of infection. There were parallel advances in radiology, dental surgery and, most importantly, anaesthetics.

During the war, it is estimated that around 11,000 patients had passed through the team’s hands and Gillies’s last war casualty patient left his care in 1921. He was twice Mentioned in Despatches, was awarded the OBE in 1918 and CBE in 1920. He was knighted in 1930.

After the war he worked as a Plastic surgeon at St. Bartholomew’s hospital, concentrating on reconstructive procedures following removal of malignant tumours, repairing hare-lips and cleft palates etc.

In 1924 he became Consulting Plastic Surgeon to the RAF and, in 1939, to the Army at Home and to the Ministry of Health. He was responsible for the expansion of plastic surgical units outside London at the beginning of the Second World War, he himself leading the team at Park Prewett Hospital, near Basingstoke, Hampshire, while his cousin Archibald MacIndoe was responsible for the unit at East Grinstead, Sussex, which became very famous.

Mcindoe et al

Four greats in the field of plastic surgery. Left to right: Rainsford Mowlem, MRCS, FRCS,
Thomas Pomfret Kilner, CBE, DM, FRCS, Sir Harold Gillies, CBE, MRCS, FRCS, LRCP, Hon FACS, Hon FRACS, and Sir Archibald McIndoe, CBE FRCS. All except Kilner were born in New Zealand ancestry. Image by kind permission of Dr Andrew Bamji FRCP

Unlike the situation in 1914, these units were up and running and ready for action for the first major influx of patients – from Dunkirk.

Harold Gillies made an enormous and unique contribution to the development of plastic surgery during the 20th century. He was a meticulous, dedicated surgeon and an inspiring and exacting teacher.  After his death in 1960 it was said: “Sir Harold Gillies’s name might perish but his influence will be immortal”.

SOURCES:

http://www.nature.com/bdj/journal/v205/n1/full/sj.bdj.2008.589.html?foxtrotcallback=true

http://www.gilliesarchives.org.uk/tonkspastels.htm

http://www.sciencemuseum.org.uk/broughttolife/people/haroldgillies

http://www.gilliesarchives.org.uk/

http://www.bbc.co.uk/guides/zxw42hv

FURTHER INFORMATION:

http://www.nzedge.com/legends/harold-gillies/

http://www.basingstokegazette.co.uk/memories/4491429.Gillies_____the_genius_of_Rooksdown/

https://www.brlsi.org/node/88811/backlinks

GRATEFUL THANKS

We are very grateful to Dr Andrew Bamji FRCP, retired Consultant in Rheumatology and Rehabilitation, President, British Society for Rheumatology 2006 – 2008 for permission to use the images of Gilies shown above.

Andrew’s personal interest in the work of Gillies has lead him to discover and preserve much of the original First World War case notes of those treated at Queen Mary’s Hospital, Sidcup, Kent.

His very informative website about can be found at: http://www.gilliesarchives.org.uk